Electrochemical Measurement Statistics

library(crossStatR)
library(ggplot2)

Development validation

This vignette accompanies development version 0.99.2. The benchmark covers selected configurations, and the validation study uses 100 datasets per metric with 99 resampling draws. These small simulations provide diagnostics; they do not establish general statistical calibration. The local study observed 24% peak false positives, 10% peak detection, 74.9% transfer interval coverage, and 43% drift interval coverage in the tested scenarios. These results limit inferential use of these methods. Report sources are scripts/benchmark.R and scripts/validate.R.

Scope of this vignette

Electrochemical measurements (cyclic voltammetry, amperometry, impedance spectroscopy, sensor calibration curves) share a common statistical shape: a measured signal that contains peaks, sits on a baseline, drifts over the course of the experiment, and must be calibrated against known concentrations to produce a number the analyst reports. crossStatR provides four functions for these workflows: adaptive_baseline() for baseline estimation, weighted_peak_fit() for multi-peak fitting, drift_correct_stat() for instrument drift correction with propagated uncertainty, and robust_lod() for limits of detection and quantification.

This vignette works through a synthetic cyclic voltammetry example that exhibits all four features. The example discusses the Currie (1968) and Hubaux-Vos (1970) LOD frameworks, what drift correction does and does not do, and where the package’s defaults can mislead the analyst.

Simulated cyclic voltammetry

The example simulates a single forward sweep from -0.2 V to 0.6 V with a Gaussian redox peak near 0.25 V, a slowly varying quadratic baseline, additive Gaussian measurement noise, and a linear drift in the baseline that depends on acquisition time.

set.seed(202)
v <- seq(-0.2, 0.6, length.out = 400)
time_index <- seq_len(length(v))                       # seconds
baseline <- 1.0 + 0.6 * v + 0.9 * v^2                  # quadratic baseline
drift     <- 0.0008 * time_index                       # linear in time
peak1     <- 12 * exp(-(v - 0.25)^2 / (2 * 0.025^2))   # faradaic peak
noise     <- rnorm(length(v), sd = 0.08)
current   <- baseline + drift + peak1 + noise
cv_df <- data.frame(v = v, current = current, time = time_index)
ggplot(cv_df, aes(x = v, y = current)) +
  geom_line(colour = "steelblue") +
  labs(x = "Potential (V)", y = "Current (µA)") +
  theme_bw()
Simulated cyclic voltammogram with a quadratic baseline, linear drift, and additive Gaussian noise. The faradaic peak sits near 0.25 V.

Simulated cyclic voltammogram with a quadratic baseline, linear drift, and additive Gaussian noise. The faradaic peak sits near 0.25 V.

Baseline estimation

adaptive_baseline() offers two backends. The default is asymmetric least squares (Eilers and Boelens, 2005), which iteratively reweights a penalised least-squares fit so the baseline tracks the lower envelope of the signal. The second backend is lowess, which the package includes as a sanity check rather than as a recommended default; it does not try to be asymmetric and will be biased upward when the signal sits well above the true baseline.

bl <- adaptive_baseline(v, current, method = "asls",
                        lambda = 1e7, p = 0.01)
print(bl)
#> <crossStatR::adaptive_baseline> method = asls
#> n = 400, converged = TRUE, iterations = 7
#> Baseline range: [0.6823, 1.832]
#> Corrected range: [-0.1727, 11.97]

Inspect the corrected signal for systematic residual structure. If the ALS baseline tracks the top of a wide peak rather than sitting below it, the penalty lambda is too small or the asymmetry parameter p is too large.

plot_df <- data.frame(
  v = rep(v, 3),
  current = c(current, bl$baseline, bl$corrected),
  what = factor(rep(c("raw", "baseline", "corrected"),
                    each = length(v)),
                levels = c("raw", "baseline", "corrected"))
)
ggplot(plot_df, aes(x = v, y = current, colour = what)) +
  geom_line() + facet_wrap(~ what, ncol = 1, scales = "free_y") +
  labs(x = "Potential (V)", y = "Current (µA)") +
  theme_bw() + theme(legend.position = "none")
Raw signal, ALS baseline, and baseline-corrected current. The corrected peak shape should be roughly symmetric and return to zero away from the peak.

Raw signal, ALS baseline, and baseline-corrected current. The corrected peak shape should be roughly symmetric and return to zero away from the peak.

Peak fitting on the baseline-corrected signal

With the baseline subtracted the example can fit the redox peak with weighted_peak_fit(). The example uses the Gaussian line shape; the Lorentzian and pseudo-Voigt shapes are available for spectra with broader, more non-Gaussian peaks.

pf <- weighted_peak_fit(v, bl$corrected, peaks = "auto",
                       n_peaks = 1, peak_shape = "gaussian")
#> Waiting for profiling to be done...
print(pf)
#> <crossStatR::weighted_peak_fit> shape = gaussian, n_peaks = 1
#> Converged: TRUE, AIC = -523.214, BIC = -507.248
#> 
#> Coefficients:
#>  peak param         est           se      ci_low     ci_high
#>     1     h 11.93930672 3.254635e-02 11.87539907 12.00332874
#>     1     c  0.24993082 7.882404e-05  0.24977585  0.25008579
#>     1     w  0.02504184 7.882404e-05  0.02488749  0.02519714

The fit returns heights, centres, and widths with nls asymptotic standard errors. The example does not pick the number of peaks by AIC automatically; an extra spurious peak in downstream analysis is usually more costly than a missed small peak, so the example leaves the count to the analyst. Inspect aic, bic, and the residual plot before committing to a fit.

Drift correction with uncertainty

The linear drift in time (the 0.0008 * time_index term) is a textbook example of instrumental drift. In a real experiment the analyst would not know the drift function in advance. The analyst would instead measure reference standards periodically and pass them to drift_correct_stat(). Here the example simulates a few reference readings:

ref_df <- data.frame(
  time = seq(20, 380, by = 40),
  y    = 0.0008 * seq(20, 380, by = 40) + rnorm(10, sd = 0.02)
)
dri <- drift_correct_stat(current, time_index, reference = ref_df,
                          drift_model = "linear")
print(dri)
#> <crossStatR::drift_correct_stat> model = linear
#> Reference time: 200.5
#> Drift fit range: [-0.003838, 0.3179]
#> Corrected signal range: [0.9265, 13.37]
#> Mean drift SE: 0.0104

What drift correction does: it fits a smooth drift model to the reference standards, anchors the corrected signal at the median reference time, and returns a delta-method standard error on the correction at each time point. The correction uncertainty is propagated from the drift model via the formula \mathrm{Var}(\hat d(t_i) - \hat d(t_{\mathrm{ref}})) = \mathrm{Var}(\hat d(t_i)) + \mathrm{Var}(\hat d(t_{\mathrm{ref}})) - 2\, \mathrm{Cov}(\hat d(t_i), \hat d(t_{\mathrm{ref}})).

What drift correction does not do: it does not make the corrected measurements independent. If the original measurements are correlated through shared noise structure, subtracting a fitted drift function does not remove that correlation. Treat the corrected measurements as the analyst would the originals for downstream independence assumptions; if the noise has temporal autocorrelation, fit a model that accounts for it (e.g. generalised least squares with a correlation structure, as discussed in Davison and Hinkley, 1997, ch. 7, in the context of bootstrap resampling for time-series data).

Limits of detection

The example uses a separate calibration experiment for the same sensor: a linear sweep of concentrations with measured currents.

set.seed(303)
conc <- seq(0, 10, length.out = 20)
resp <- 0.5 + 2.0 * conc + rnorm(length(conc), sd = 0.25)
cal <- lm(resp ~ conc)

The Currie (1968) critical-value approach gives a single-point LOD based on controlling the false-positive and false-negative rates. The classical 3 * sigma / slope rule corresponds to alpha = beta = 0.00135 (one-sided z = 3). The Hubaux-Vos (1970) prediction-interval approach solves a fixed-point equation for the concentration at which the lower prediction bound on the response at that concentration equals the upper prediction bound at zero concentration. It is more conservative than Currie when the calibration sample size is small because it accounts for the calibration uncertainty itself.

robust_lod(cal, method = "currie")
#> <crossStatR::robust_lod> method = currie
#> LOD = 0.174  (95% CI: [0.1172, 0.2301])
#> LOQ = 0.5288
#> Slope = 2.003, intercept = 0.5085, residual SE = 0.1981 (df = 18)
#> Blank SD = 0.1059
#> Heteroscedastic noise detected: LOD recomputed with local sigma.
#> False positive rate = 0.050, false negative rate = 0.050
robust_lod(cal, method = "hubaux_vos")
#> <crossStatR::robust_lod> method = hubaux_vos
#> LOD = 0.1886  (95% CI: [0.1294, 0.2518])
#> LOQ = 0.5305
#> Slope = 2.003, intercept = 0.5085, residual SE = 0.1981 (df = 18)
#> Blank SD = 0.1063
#> Heteroscedastic noise detected: LOD recomputed with local sigma.
#> False positive rate = 0.050, false negative rate = 0.050

Both methods assume the calibration is linear in the relevant range and that the noise is approximately Gaussian. If the calibration is nonlinear near zero, the LOD is unreliable. If the noise is heteroscedastic, the function detects this (a lowess fit of |r| on x whose max-to-min ratio exceeds 2) and recomputes the LOD using a local sigma at the LOD estimate. The Monte Carlo CI on the LOD simulates from the asymptotic distribution of (\hat\alpha, \hat\beta, \hat\sigma) and recomputes the LOD for each simulation; for small calibration samples this underestimates the true uncertainty, and the analyst should report it as a lower bound.

The documentation does not recommend the blank_sd method as a default. It uses the IUPAC 3 * sigma / slope form with no calibration-based standard error; use it only when the analyst has a small number of explicit blank measurements and no usable calibration.

What to take away

For electrochemical work: subtract the baseline with ALS, fit peaks with weighted_peak_fit(), correct drift with reference standards (not the running-median fallback), and report a Currie or Hubaux-Vos LOD with a Monte Carlo CI. Do not claim that drift-corrected measurements are independent; they are not. If the downstream test assumes independence and the original noise was correlated, the drift correction will not save the analyst.

Measured Caltech electrochemistry data

Soedarmadji and Gregoire (2021) provide the plate 3540 electrochemistry analysis dataset at CaltechDATA. The packaged table contains derived diagnostics from 29 CA2 and 29 CV3 current traces. Material sample identifiers denote distinct materials; they do not establish independent replicates of a treatment. Non-finite current/time rows are counted explicitly before exclusion.

caltech <- read.csv(system.file(
  "extdata", "caltech-current-summary.csv", package = "crossStatR"))
aggregate(cbind(input_rows, excluded_rows, observations) ~ analysis,
          data = caltech, FUN = sum)
#>   analysis input_rows excluded_rows observations
#> 1        1        870            29          841
#> 2        2       2163            29         2134
head(caltech[c("analysis", "sample", "mean_photocurrent_uA",
               "slope_uA_per_s", "difference_noise_uA")])
#>   analysis sample mean_photocurrent_uA slope_uA_per_s difference_noise_uA
#> 1        1  13978             1.084807     -0.1014204          0.08392229
#> 2        1  13983             3.158990     -0.1735056          0.09902733
#> 3        1  13989             2.790028     -0.1427921          0.09718779
#> 4        1  13995             2.604641     -0.1255870          0.08403356
#> 5        1  14001             5.472738     -0.1990770          0.13635118
#> 6        1  14007             4.699617     -0.2110722          0.22275001

The local workflow checked 348 numerical results across 58 curves and 2,975 retained observations. Means, SDs, OLS coefficients, and successive difference SDs were compared with base R. Smoothing checks required finite output of the expected length. These checks establish numerical agreement for the measured inputs, rather than validation of a physical model. The difference SD also contains genuine signal changes and is not an independent estimate of instrumental noise.

Source processing and checks are reproducible with scripts/validate_caltech.R. The test data is taken from https://doi.org/10.25989/198p-1x22. Attribution: Soedarmadji, E., and Gregoire, J. (2021). Materials Experiment and Analysis Database: Electrochemistry analysis, Electrochemistry measurements, Material library with V,Ca,Ar,O on plate(s) 3540. CaltechDATA, v1. https://doi.org/10.25989/198p-1x22.

References

  • Currie, L. A. (1968). Limits for qualitative detection and quantitative determination. Application to radiochemistry. Analytical Chemistry, 40, 586-593. Source.

  • Davison, A. C. and Hinkley, D. V. (1997). Bootstrap Methods and their Application. Cambridge University Press. Source.

  • Eilers, P. H. C. and Boelens, H. F. M. (2005). Baseline Correction with Asymmetric Least Squares Smoothing. Unpublished manuscript. Source.